Cabinet Comparison · Westchester County
Plain & Fancy vs StarMark Cabinets
A side-by-side comparison of Plain & Fancy and StarMark kitchen cabinets for Westchester County homeowners — construction, price, selection, and the right choice for your renovation.
| Plain & Fancy | StarMark | |
|---|---|---|
| Tier | Custom | Semi-Custom to Custom |
| Price Range (installed) | $35,000–$100,000+ installed | $16,000–$38,000 installed |
| Construction | Fully custom — any size, hand-applied finishes, Pennsylvania manufacturing | Custom sizing available, inset door option, made in South Dakota |
| Lead Time | 8–12 weeks | 6–8 weeks |
| Best For | Traditional and transitional luxury kitchens — exceptional door style depth and finish quality | Custom capabilities at competitive pricing — inset and custom sizing available |
Plain & Fancy — Strengths
- ✓Fully custom
- ✓Exceptional traditional door depth
- ✓Hand-applied finishes
- ✓Made in PA
Considerations
- →Premium price
- →Longer lead time
- →Requires professional specification
StarMark — Strengths
- ✓Custom sizing
- ✓Inset door option
- ✓Good painted finish quality
- ✓Made in USA
Considerations
- →Less established in Westchester market
- →Longer lead than standard semi-custom
Our recommendation
Both Plain & Fancy (Custom) and StarMark (Semi-Custom to Custom) are cabinet lines Three Brothers Kitchens and Baths has experience specifying and installing in Westchester County. The right choice depends on your budget, design goals, and the specific characteristics of your kitchen project. We recommend visiting our Chappaqua or Congers showroom where you can see and touch both lines in person.
Two Showrooms · No Appointment Necessary
Compare Plain & Fancy and StarMark In Person
Visit our showrooms to see both lines. Mon–Sat 9am–5:30pm. No appointment necessary.